Need a little mystery? You’re in luck today. We’ve compiled a bunch of the best mystery movies on Hulu. Hulu is the go-to platform for engaging movies & shows.
From captivating plots to surprising twists & turns, these best mystery movies on Hulu will keep you hooked.
The mind-bending, suspenseful storyline with spectacular characters makes these movies a must-watch. You can pick the ones that suit your needs or binge-watch all of them & have a great mystery movie on Hulu Marathon.
10 Best Mystery Movies On Hulu:
We came up with not one but the 10 best mystery movies on Hulu that you can watch right away. All you need is a Hulu subscription, and you’re ready!
1. Before The Devil Knows You’re Dead [2007]:
- IMDB Rating: 7.3
- Directed By: Sidney Lumet
- Box Office: $25 Million
- Starring: Philip Seymour, Hoffman, Ethan Hawke, Marisa Tomei, and Albert Finney
The title sounds intriguing, right? Before The Devil Knows You’re Dead focuses on the story of Andy and his brother Hank. The two brothers decide to rob their own parent’s jewelry store. Things turn twisted when their father is on a mission to hunt down the criminals without knowing it’s his sons.
On a production budget of $18 million, the movie grossed around $25 million. The movie became one of 2007’s ten most influential American films at the 2007 AFI Awards by the American Film Institute.
Before The Devil Knows You’re Dead has been nominated for multiple accolades, including the Satellite Award for Best Ensemble: Motion Picture, the Gotham Independent Film Award for Best Ensemble Performance, and more.
2. Shutter Island [2010]:
- IMDB Rating: 8.2
- Directed By: Martin Scorsese
- Box Office: $294.8 Million
- Starring: Leonardo DiCaprio, Mark Ruffalo, Ben Kingsley, Michelle Williams, Emily Mortimer, Patricia Clarkson, and Max von Sydow
Trust us when we say you will love this movie. Shutter Island will keep you guessing. The movie follows the story of two US Marshals, Teddy Daniels and Chuck Aule. They are sent to a remote island to investigate the disappearance of a missing patient from an asylum.
In the process, Teddy Daniels is met with a shocking truth. The audience loved the performance of Leonardo DiCaprio and Mark Ruffalo. Shutter Island became one of the top ten films of 2010. On a production budget of $80 million, the movie grossed around $294.8 million.
Shutter Island has been nominated for many accolades, and Leonardo DiCaprio won the Teen Choice Award for Choice Movie Actor: Horror/Thriller. Shutter Island is, without a doubt, the best mystery movie on Hulu.
3. Death On The Nile [2022]:
- IMDB Rating: 6.3
- Directed By: Kenneth Branagh
- Box Office: $137.3 Million
- Starring: Tom Bateman, Annette Bening, Kenneth Branagh, Russell Brand, Ali Fazal, Dawn French, Gal Gadot, Armie Hammer, Rose Leslie, Emma Mackey, Sophie Okonedo, Jennifer Saunders, and Letitia Wright
Need a perfect mystery crime? Death On The Nile will keep you hooked. The movie is a sequel to Murder on the Orient Express [2017]. On a production budget of around $90–100 million, Death On The Nile grossed $137.3 million. The movie has been known as ‘the most watched movie across all platforms’ in the week of April 2022.
The official synopsis of the movie reads, “Belgian sleuth Hercule Poirot’s Egyptian vacation aboard a glamorous river steamer turns into a terrifying search for a murderer when a picture-perfect couple’s idyllic honeymoon is tragically cut short.” Death On The Nile is quite popular among the audience because of the investigations of psychology and morality.
4. Gone Girl [2014]:
- IMDB Rating: 8.1
- Directed By: David Fincher
- Box Office: $369.3 Million
- Starring: Ben Affleck, Rosamund Pike, Neil Patrick Harris, Tyler Perry, and Carrie Coon
Gone Girl follows the engaging and suspenseful story of Nick Dunne’s wife. Nick’s wife, Amy, has disappeared, and the media is now focused on him. Amy’s disappearance took place on their fifth wedding anniversary.
An investigation takes place that reveals a lot of hidden secrets. Nick is now the prime suspect. On a production of $61 million, the movie grossed around $369.3 million. Gone Girl became Fincher’s highest-grossing film.
The movie even received multiple nominations, including an Academy Award, BAFTA Award, Golden Globe Award, Screen Actors Guild Award, and more. Gone Girl also became one of the most profitable films of 2014.
5. Watcher [2022]:
- IMDB Rating: 6.3
- Directed By: Chloe Okuno
- Box Office: $3.2 Million
- Starring: Maika Monroe, Karl Glusman, and Burn Gorman
Next, we have Watcher on the rundown of the best mystery movies on Hulu. Watcher is a psychological thriller that focuses on the story of a serial killer stalking the city. A young beautiful actress moved to town recently and is being watched by a mysterious stranger.
The movie is both striking and sensational, according to the audience. On a production budget of $5 million, Watcher grossed around $3.2 million worldwide. The great writing and directing have been widely appreciated.
6. Girl [2020]:
- IMDB Rating: 4.9
- Directed By: Chad Faust
- Box Office: $25,995
- Starring: Bella Thorne, Chad Faust, Elizabeth Saunders, and Mickey Rourke
The compelling story of Girl will keep you hooked. A young girl visits her hometown to kill her abusive father. Then, she learns that her father is already killed by someone else. The deeper she gets into the situation, the more she learns secrets about her family legacy.
Bella Thorne as Girl has been widely praised by the audience. The storyline will leave you wanting for more. Girl movie has also been nominated for accolades. This is one of the best mystery movies on Hulu to watch right now.
7. Boston Strangler [2023]:
- IMDB Rating: 6.5
- Directed By: Matt Ruskin
- Starring: Keira Knightley, Carrie Coon, Alessandro Nivola, and Chris Cooper
If you want to watch a new movie, Boston Strangler will be the perfect pick. A reported Loretta McLaughlin is the first person who discovered a series of mysterious murders, put it together, and finally broke the story of the Boston Strangler.
Boston Strangler is the city’s most notorious killer. The movie is set in the 1960s in Boston. The Boston Strangler has killed around 13 women. What makes the movie more engaging is that it is mostly historically accurate.
The accuracy has piqued the audience’s interest from the crimes to the investigations. Kiera Knightley, as the reporter, is quite talented.
8. Enemy Of The State [1998]:
- IMDB Rating: 7.3
- Directed By: Tony Scott
- Box Office: $250.8 Million
- Starring: Will Smith, Gene Hackman, Jon Voight, Regina King, Loren Dean, Jake Busey, Scott Caan, Barry Pepper, and Gabriel Byrne
Mystery with action is the perfect combination. Enemy of the State is focused on the story of Robert Dean, who accidentally gets hold of a mysterious videotape. The videotape changes Robert Dean’s life forever. It contains evidence of Congressman Phil Hammersley’s murder.
After getting deeper into the situation, he comes under the surveillance of NSA agents. There’s mystery, drama, action, and thriller. Enemy Of The State garnered widespread praise from the audience.
The movie grossed around $250.8 million on a production budget of $90 million. A lot of the audience praised the chemistry between Smith and Hackman. The movie is worth watching, making it one of the best mystery movies on Hulu.
9. Hell Or High Water [2016]:
- IMDB Rating: 7.6
- Directed By: David Mackenzie
- Box Office: $37.9 Million
- Starring: Jeff Bridges, Chris Pine, Ben Foster, and Gil Birmingham
Hell or High Water is a Western crime mystery movie. The movie focuses on an ex-convict and his brother. Toby and his brother Tanner are on a dangerous mission to rob banks. The two cannot afford the mortgage payments and carry out a series of robbing banks to save their family ranch.
On a production budget of $12 million, the movie grossed around $37.9 million. The movie even received widespread acclaim for performances by Pine, Foster, and Bridges. In addition, Hell or High Water has been nominated for Oscars, Independent Spirit Award, Satellite Award, and more.
10. Run [2020]:
- IMDB Rating: 6.7
- Directed By: Aneesh Chaganty
- Box Office: $5.2 Million
- Starring: Sarah Paulson and Kiera Allen
You have to watch this horror mystery movie on Hulu. Run’s plot will keep you guessing. The movie follows the story of a teenager, Chloe, who is isolated. Soon, Chloe starts second-guessing her mother’s intention and doubting her. Chloe’s mother has dark secrets.
On a production budget of $1 million, Run grossed $5.2 worldwide, making it a success. The movie became ‘Hulu’s most successful original film upon its release.’ This psychological thriller is worth a watch. The exciting performance of the duo has been praised, too!
Frequently Asked Questions:
The best psychological thrillers on Hulu are Boston Strangler [2023], Shutter Island [2010], Black Swan [2010], and The Sixth Sense [1999].
The best murder mystery movies on Hulu are Death on The Nile [2022], Boston Strangler [2023], and All Good Things [2010].
Yes! The best mystery movie on Hulu 2023 is Boston Strangler [2023].
Conclusion:
Whatever you pick to watch, it will be worth your time. Warning! You will be hooked. Which movies are you planning to watch? Feel free to let us know in the comment box. You can even suggest the best mystery movies on Hulu. Need more movie/show suggestions like this on different genres? Stay tuned with us.
While sipping coffee, you can find Ayman writing about various topics like movie recommendations, gaming, and tech. She has always loved writing and is now following her passion. Ayman is constantly pushing herself to achieve new heights of success and is always ready to take on new challenges and explore new opportunities.
